“The key is not to prioritize what’s on your schedule, but to schedule your priorities.”
Key Takeaways
-
- Timecard approval is one of the last opportunities to catch payroll errors before employees are paid.
- Reviewing attendance patterns, overtime, and timecard exceptions can help reduce labour costs and payroll corrections.
- Comparing scheduled hours to actual hours often reveals operational issues that would otherwise go unnoticed.
- A consistent payroll review process helps managers identify trends before they become larger problems.
Why a Strict Payroll Review Process Matters
For many managers, approving employee timecards is viewed as an administrative task that happens at the end of each pay period. Hours are reviewed, payroll is submitted, and the process repeats itself a few weeks later. Treating timecard approval as a simple payroll step, however, can cause managers to overlook valuable information. Timecards often reveal attendance issues, labour cost trends, scheduling problems, and payroll inaccuracies long before they become major concerns.
A missed punch, an unauthorized overtime shift, or a pattern of late arrivals may seem insignificant in isolation, but these issues can create payroll corrections, increase labour costs, and frustrate employees when left unchecked. Before approving payroll, managers should take the time to review several key areas that can improve accuracy and provide valuable operational insights.
The Step-by-Step Employee Timecard Approval Checklist
1. Check for Missing or Incomplete Punches
One of the most common payroll issues is a missing punch. Employees may forget to clock in, forget to clock out, or accidentally create duplicate punches. While these mistakes are usually unintentional, they can create payroll inaccuracies that require manual corrections later.
Before approving timecards, review:
- Missing clock-ins
- Missing clock-outs
- Duplicate punches
- Extremely short shifts
- Unusually long shifts
The sooner these issues are identified, the easier they are to correct while details are still fresh.
2. Audit Unexpected Overtime and Labour Leakage
Overtime can significantly impact labour costs, particularly in retail, hospitality, healthcare, and other shift-based workplaces. When reviewing timecards, look beyond the total overtime hours and ask why they occurred.
Consider:
- Was the overtime approved?
- Was it necessary?
- Did staffing shortages contribute?
- Is the same employee consistently working overtime?
Repeated overtime often points to larger operational issues such as understaffing, inaccurate forecasting, or uneven workload distribution. Rather than simply approving overtime hours, managers should use payroll review as an opportunity to understand the factors driving them.
3. Compare Scheduled Hours vs. Actual Hours Worked
One of the most valuable payroll reviews managers can perform is comparing scheduled hours against actual worked hours.
Look for employees who:
- Consistently clock in early
- Frequently stay past their scheduled end times
- Regularly arrive late
- Routinely work more hours than originally scheduled
These trends can indicate scheduling issues, workload imbalances, or attendance concerns. For example, if an employee is arriving ten to fifteen minutes early every shift, that may seem insignificant, but across dozens of shifts and multiple employees, those extra minutes can add up quickly.
This is where workforce management tools can help. TimeWellScheduled allows managers to compare scheduled and worked hours, apply customizable grace periods, and track attendance exceptions such as late arrivals. Instead of discovering patterns only when payroll is due, managers can identify and address them throughout the pay period.
4. Verify Break Compliance & Employment Standards
Missed breaks, shortened breaks, or incorrectly recorded breaks can create compliance concerns and payroll inaccuracies depending on applicable employment standards.
Review timecards for:
- Missing meal breaks
- Unusually short breaks
- Unusually long breaks
- Employees consistently skipping breaks
Patterns are often more important than individual incidents. A single missed break may be understandable, but repeated occurrences may indicate staffing challenges or process issues that require attention.
5. Review Employee Notes and Exception Logs
Employees often submit notes that explain unusual activity during a pay period.
These may include:
- Sick time
- Vacation requests
- Training hours
- Meetings
- Shift swaps
- Approved schedule changes
Reviewing these notes before approving payroll helps ensure time records accurately reflect what occurred and reduces the likelihood of payroll disputes later.
6. Perform a Final Payroll Review
Before approving employee timecards, perform one final review using a simple checklist:
- Are all punches complete?
- Has overtime been reviewed and approved?
- Are break/meal records accurate?
- Have attendance exceptions been reviewed?
- Have all manual edits been verified?
- Do actual hours align reasonably with scheduled hours?
- Have employee notes and exceptions been reviewed?
Taking a few extra minutes at this stage can prevent hours of payroll corrections later.
Conclusion
Timecard approval should not be viewed as the final administrative step before payroll is processed. Instead, treat it as a management review process that helps identify payroll risks, attendance issues, scheduling inaccuracies, and labour cost trends before they become larger problems.
